-- Start log: Wednesday, October 6, 2004 9:22:08 pm ASI Meeting Server time-- MikeD-2 says, "thanks Dana" kokhmmm says, "Membership services and processing is first up." Greg-1 says, "She's on her way." Greg-1 says, ":)" Nancy-1 says, "We had 8 renews and 1 new subscription. She's still having computer problems, but was able to get the membships caught up." Nancy-1 says, "Sorry! I'm on the phone too. :)" MikeD-2 says, "I guess tha ads aren't helping at all" kokhmmm says, "I new - that's good. We need many more. The total is still getting smaller." garygray says, "Nabxy do you know where the new member came from?!" MikeD-2 says, "doesn't matter if it's from the ads, it's not enough to pay for them" garygray says, "Yes, the process or ad isn't working for some reason!" Nancy-1 says, "I really don't know." kokhmmm says, "Let's give the ads a bit more time." john-r says, "the last member is from france" MikeD-2 says, "we'd need 30 new members a month for the ads to be worthwhile" john-r says, "look in team director, choose current members, then sort by member number" kokhmmm says, "That must be the fellow I met at the Mars Convention (from France)" MikeD-2 says, "we could try talking to the Moon Society members in Orkut" Scottyg-1 has disconnected. The housekeeper arrives to remove Scottyg-1. DaveW-1 arrives. john-r says, "Hi Dave" DaveW-1 says, "hello" Greg-1 says, "No progress on the renewal notice letters. I've been swampado." garygray says, "Hi Dave!" MikeD-2 thwaps Greg-1 with a rolled-up newspaper. "Bad! Bad! Bad!!!" john-r says, "swampado - is that worse then burried :)" MikeD-2 says, "it's drowning in ados" irs says, "Is burried worse than buried?" kokhmmm says, "I had offered to do renewal letters to hardcopy subscribers, but I am having trouble just getting MMM done along with the new duties." john-r says, "Hi Ian ! noo, myt spellin is alfull :)" Greg-1 says, "Golly! Welcome to my nightmare, Peter!" irs says, "Ah, that must be the editor in me ." Greg-1 says, "Does anyone else around here speak mail/merge?" kokhmmm says, "eval -)" Scottyg-1 has arrived. Scottyg-1 says, "Oops." MikeD-2 says, "I speak mailmerge" MikeD-2 says, "sort ot" MikeD-2 says, "sortof too" john-r says, "For those like me, editors are are greatly appriciated(sp)" Nancy-1 says, "Is that an offer to take on the mail/merge challenge, Mike?" MikeD-2 says, "what mail/merge challenge?" john-r says, "biab" Severy-6 has arrived. kokhmmm says, "John is working on fingermerge" MikeD-2 says, "the funny thing is that I was just about to mention mail/merge to Peter" Severy-6 says, "Good evening, everyone! Sorry I'm late, as usual :-(" kokhmmm says, "Hi, Randall. We're on Membership services, and I hereby cede the gavel to you." garygray says, "Hi Randall!" MikeD-2 says, "just make sure you grab the gavel and not the obo Randall" Nancy-1 says, "Hi Randall!" Greg-1 says, "Mike, we need a system for automatically generating paper renewal notices." Severy-6 says, "Oboe is put away for the evening until tomorrow :-)" MikeD-2 says, "generating them from what Greg?" Greg-1 says, "We can generate a mail/merge file from the database and Randall has already done a lot on generating the report." Severy-6 says, "Team Director will generate a spreadshet file of everyone that should get a renewal notice, and we need a mail merge Word document that we can feed those addresses into to generate renewal letters" MikeD-2 says, "I've done mailmerge from teamdir once, about 2 years ago" Greg-1 says, "What we need is the letter and mail/merge templates, plus a clearly written procedure that Missy can follow to print out the letters and envelopes." Greg-1 says, "That clearly written procedure is the turning stone." MikeD-2 says, "I think I can handle that, it might take a couple of days as long as someone else provides me with the wordies" Greg-1 says, "Scotty, did you do anything with Mary Cooper's request to use funds from her account to purchase a Moon Society membership?" Severy-6 says, "Can someone send Mike the last version of the renewal letters?" MikeD-2 says, "what format do these need to be?" MikeD-2 says, "will Word doc file suffice?" MikeD-2 says, "or do you need something else?" Severy-6 says, "I think the renewal letters were in Word doc format" MikeD-2 says, "What does Missy have availabl to her?" Scottyg-1 says, "I haven't seen Mary's request." Greg-1 says, "Scotty, oops!" MikeD-2 says, "Let me rephrase that, what wordprocessing software does Missy have available to her?" Greg-1 says, "Microsoft Word." Nancy-1 says, "She has Microsoft Word." MikeD-2 says, "Ok, so Word Docs would be the most compatible for her then" Greg-1 says, "Scotty, I'll just pay the funds to Mary's PayPal account and then she can use the funds to join the Moon Society. Does the Moon Society accept PayPal?" Greg-1 says, "Mike, yup." Scottyg-1 says, "Greg, no." Greg-1 says, "Rats." MikeD-2 says, "I'm not sure about transferring a whole mail/merge setup however, it may be better for me to generate them and email them to her or upload them to a directory on the server" kokhmmm says, "Scotty, is there a problem with PayPall?" Scottyg-1 says, "We aren't set up with PayPal." MikeD-2 says, "PayPal is something we should look at, but don't use the main account" kokhmmm says, "What I am asking, is is there a reason you prefer not being set up with Paypal?" kokhmmm says, "Like too much hastle, too high a fee?" Severy-6 says, "I've been working on a new registration module for Team Director for NSS, once that is completed, I'll start looking at implementing it for the Moon Society" Severy-6 says, "It has PayPal processing built in..." kokhmmm says, "Any other new features, Randall?" Severy-6 says, "Lots, Peter!" john-r says, "appox time Randall, 2months?" Scottyg-1 says, "Setting up anything like PayPal requires initial and ongoing time and effort. If I perceived a large demand for PayPal, I would make that effort. But this is the first time its been mentioned." Severy-6 says, "My goal is to finish everything before the NSS fall conference in a little over a month, John" john-r says, "ahhh TY" MikeD-2 says, "Scotty, PayPal might actually help increase the overseas membership, but note the use of the word might" kokhmmm says, "Will it be worth a special report to our members?" Severy-6 says, "Yes, there will also be an overhaul of My Moon Society as part of that, as well as new web-based access to mailing lists and a variety of other things" Scottyg-1 says, "PayPal isn't much help for international members. PayPal only accepts a few currencies so it still leaves most of the world s.o.l." Scottyg-1 says, "Credit cards are by far themost universal solution." MikeD-2 says, "PayPal takes Euros and Pounds" Severy-6 says, "Ok, anything else on Membership Processing for tonight?" kokhmmm says, "As to registration options, has everyone gotten my mail suggesting a $20 (electronic newsletter) first year only registration fee for those recruited by chapters and local contacts (to make their growth efforts easier)?" kokhmmm says, "Jumped the gun!" MikeD-2 says, "Peter, that would really just require a password protected signup area for chapter leaders" kokhmmm says, "Explain, Mike" MikeD-2 says, "but I'm sure there are other issues" Greg-1 reads the meeting agenda MikeD-2 says, "In order to avoid abuse you would have a second, private, area for chapter leaders to signup new members" kokhmmm says, "I see. That should work." Scottyg-1 says, "Yes, we could provide an alternate entry point for the registration system accessible only to chapter leaders." MikeD-2 says, "I think each chapter could have it's own login and password which would allow tracking" Greg-1 says, "I have a policy question in the Membership Services area: Would we consider a complementary membership for someone who makes a substantial contribution to the Moon Society's work?" kokhmmm says, "The rate I am suggesting is the same we offer to students and seniors." MikeD-2 says, "I would Greg" kokhmmm says, "Only for new chapter recruits it would be available first year only. Then $35 (unless student or senior)" Greg-1 says, "There are two sides to that issue: On the one hand, it's a minor encouragement to get people to do neat stuff. On the other hand, we'd be constantly faced with having to decide what a "substantial contribution" is." MikeD-2 says, "we'd have to predefine substantial" kokhmmm says, "Greg, I like that idea, so long as it isn't overused." Greg-1 says, "That's hard to do, Mike." Greg-1 says, "The specific case is Mary Cooper again. She is building a 3D, interactive, online lunar world." Greg-1 says, "That's SUBSTANTIAL!" MikeD-2 says, "If you calculate it as $s/hr for hours worked, Randall has enough credit to give us all free memberships" MikeD-2 says, "That's substantial, if she finishes it" Greg-1 says, "FYI, Mary Cooper is grandmamojo in ASI MOO." MikeD-2 says, "or gets it to a point where the rest of us can finish it" Greg-1 says, "Have you visited the world, Mike?" MikeD-2 says, "no I haven't, I didn;t know I could" Greg-1 says, "Right now, you can wander around on a lunar landscape under a dome." Greg-1 says, "She is looking for guidance to build the Luna City Hotel." MikeD-2 says, "I thought we said domes didn't work?" Greg-1 says, "Right. I told her that." Greg-1 says, "So part of that guidance would be to build a cavern." Greg-1 says, "Which I just told her." kokhmmm says, "They don't unless they are pseudo domes, spheres in which the bottom half if utilities, factories and other out of sight things below a public landscape." Scottyg-1 says, "Greg, is the "wander around under a dome" a 3D implementation?" Greg-1 says, "Peter, right." john-r says, "Greg do you mean no cost for say 1 year -- or 20 for the st yr?" john-r says, "st=1st" MikeD-2 says, "John, if she pulls this off properly, I'd say life-membership" MikeD-2 says, "either that or royalties from the earnings" kokhmmm says, "Wil access to this arena be free, or will it require membership?" MikeD-2 says, "I would suggest access on a pay per bandwidth used basis" Greg-1 says, "Peter, she says how about a public visitors center and the rest of the world members-only?" Greg-1 says, "People could have their own apartments and decorate them they way they want to in the members-only area." MikeD-2 says, "is this a bit like the Active Worlds idea?" kokhmmm says, "I like that idea, Greg. " MikeD-2 says, "It's what the MOO should be" MikeD-2 says, "But the MOO can't support that" Greg-1 says, "Yeah, it sounds really great." Greg-1 says, "She would create a world using Adobe Atmosphere, not the MOO." MikeD-2 says, "can we visit what she's done already?" Greg-1 says, "We'd have to work the login control software." Greg-1 says, "Maybe that could use the MOO membership datbase." kokhmmm says, "Would the visitor need special software?" MikeD-2 says, "Adobe Atmosphere is ok, Active Worlds is better, but they'll only host it themseves or charge $20000" MikeD-2 says, "You'd need Adobe Atmosphere client" Nancy-1 says, " http://www.artistichabitats.com/Atmosphere/AH3d/Lunar/LunaCity_Launcher.html" Greg-1 says, "The launcher automagically takes you to the Atmosphere client." MikeD-2 says, "I guess I need the plugin" Greg-1 says, "The better your graphics card and the faster your machine, the better it works." MikeD-2 says, "Not in Linux it doesn't" Greg-1 says, "Oh. Yeah." Greg-1 says, "I've only tried it in Windows." Nancy-1 says, "Atmosphere client is needed first: http://www.artistichabitats.com/Atmosphere/AtmospherePlayer216.zip" Greg-1 says, "You can also get the player from the Adobe site, but sometimes the Adobe site can't get through firewalls." Greg-1 says, "Pop-up blockers can stop it, too." john-r [to keep]: the meeting -tonight rolling- i lkie the concept, but need to conside how it may help to bring in paying members MikeD-2 says, "Ah, popup blockers, that could explain it" Greg-1 says, "John, I'm thinking screen shots and a free public area." Greg-1 says, "... to bring in members." Greg-1 says, "I think what to do with it would be up to us, but Mary seems eager to create it." john-r says, "ahh" kokhmmm says, "What is her name for this environment?" Greg-1 says, "Whatever we want it to be." john-r says, "i need to make a phone call," john-r says, "bib" MikeD-2 says, "John, it's definitely for DLSer" john-r has disconnected. Greg-1 says, "How about 'Luna City'?" MikeD-2 says, "John, it's definitely for DLSers" MikeD-2 says, "rats" kokhmmm says, "DLSers or DSLers?" Greg-1 says, "dizzlers?" MikeD-2 says, "DSLers" MikeD-2 says, "ok, it doesn't work with Linux and it froze my Windows machine" kokhmmm says, "I gave up cable but will have DSL by next meeting" MikeD-2 says, "It also only seems to work with MSIE" kokhmmm says, "Will it work on Mac?" Greg-1 says, "Peter, that's the serious shortcoming of Adobe Atmosphere." MikeD-2 says, "I'm hoping to give up DSL for cable, the cable over here is almost 3 times faster than the DSL" Greg-1 says, "Mary expects that there will be a Mac client by the end of the year but right now they are working on standardizing the definition of the 3D environment." Greg-1 says, "It'll probably be OS-X only." john-r has connected. kokhmmm says, "Well that seriously limits its ability to draw in new members, or even visitors, especially if it gets a lot of people frustrated." kokhmmm says, "I have OS-X" Greg-1 says, "Yeah, I'm guessing that most Mac users have gone to OS-X by now, so that's good." Greg-1 says, "(I'm a curmudgeon. Still running OS 9.2. But I have a fleet of Windows boxes.)" kokhmmm says, "With flowers or just green stuff?" Greg-1 says, "I've had to bite bitter bullet and acknowledge that great majority of folks use Windows. :(" Severy-6 chuckles. Greg-1 says, "Kinda moldy-looking, Peter." Severy-6 says, "That must have hurt, Greg! :-)" kokhmmm says, "You can run windows on OS-X, Greg, that's why many are returning." Greg-1 says, "It hurts daily, Randall." john-r says, "can i have ice creame? please" Greg-1 says, "Randall, Mary Cooper says Hi!" MikeD-2 says, "nah, it kay eye double ells my windows box for some reason" Greg-1 says, "(By now everyone has figured out what the business call is about, altough we called Mary about totally different stuff.)" kokhmmm says, "Hi, Mary" Severy-6 says, "Hi, Mary!" MikeD-2 says, "Hi Mary" Greg-1 says, "Gaelan says Hi, too." Greg-1 says, "(Please forgive me for dominating the meeting with this. It was a target of opportunity, y'see.)" MikeD-2 says, "Hi Smeddum" Greg-1 says, "Hmm... if all the folks who are interested are signed in to the lunar environment I can stop yakking about it here." MikeD-2 says, "I can't get into it, my computer keeps freezing" Greg-1 says, "That happens after sunset on the moon, Mike." Severy-6 laughs. Greg-1 says, "It also happens when you try to run six dozen operating systems on the same machine!" Severy-6 says, "I went into a building, and it's frozen at the moment, it may be downloading something" Greg-1 says, "Randall, that's probably it." Severy-6 says, "Yup, it's back" irs says, "So, it's neat? I don't even try looking at graphics from this computer, let alone interactive 3-d whatevers." Greg-1 says, "Mary says, "You know what prototypes are all about." This is a prototype, but it give us a window where we can look forward to what we can do with the technology." Severy-6 says, "It's dark in there :-)" Nancy-1 says, "Yes, it's really neat!" Severy-6 says, "Ooh, pretty stars!" Greg-1 says, "My God! It's full of stars!" Severy-6 laughs. kokhmmm says, "Are there any other kind? (of stars?)" Greg-1 says, "Look around. You'll see the Earth." Greg-1 says, "The tower is 400 feet high." Greg-1 says, "You can jump off it." Greg-1 says, "It won't hurt. Much." Severy-6 says, "Yeah, I saw the Earth" Greg-1 says, "Randall, look for the colored squares to find the entrance to the elevator." Greg-1 says, "The rotating colored squares indicate a portal." MikeD-2 says, "from 400 feet altitude on the moon, what would your final velocity be?" Severy-6 says, "Yeah, I figured that part out :-)" Greg-1 says, "The Earth is actually a 3D object. Gaelen was sitting on it. :)" Greg-1 says, "(I'm not in there right now. If I loaded it on this little machine it would hose the MOO.)" Greg-1 says, "Mike, let's see... v^2 = 2 * a * s..." MikeD-2 says, "problem is I don't know the lunar equivalent of g" kokhmmm says, "1/6th approximately" MikeD-2 says, "which means you'd only reach about 1/36th the velocity?" kokhmmm says, "1/6th of 32 ft per second squared" MikeD-2 says, "oh god, you guys use imperial equations, I forgot" Severy-6 says, "I seem to have ended up back outside the tower, so I guess I went off the roof somehow" Greg-1 says, "Using 1/6 g, falling 400 feet gives a final velocity of 65.5 feet per second." Greg-1 says, "Roughly 20 m/sec" Greg-1 says, "*splat*" MikeD-2 says, "that's still pretty fast" Greg-1 says, "That's discounting air drag." kokhmmm says, "We are 1 hr and 37 minutes into our session tonight. How about us getting back to work?" Severy-6 says, "Yup, where were we? Still on Membership Processing?" kokhmmm says, "Let's move on to registration options." Greg-1 says, "Good idea, Peter! :)" kokhmmm says, "I brought up the $20 electronic first year only option for those recruited by chapters and local contacts" kokhmmm says, "Does this need more consideration or can we send it to the Board?" Greg-1 says, "I'm a little confused about how we distinguish people recruited by chapters and local contacts." MikeD-2 says, "it involves some work for Randall and Scotty" kokhmmm says, "If the Board considers it, I'd like us also to look at giving the registering person the option of adding additional money for special purposes chosen by the member" MikeD-2 says, "They would only join from a certain page with certain private chapter logins" kokhmmm says, "Mike suggested that the chapter leader or local contact have a way to confirm that the recruit is just that." Greg-1 says, "Hmm... so we'd need to write some new software." Greg-1 says, "Which means it might be at least a couple of months before we could even get started on implementing it." MikeD-2 says, "I think it could backfire in about a year Peter, they wouldn't renew when the bill for $35 arrived" Greg-1 says, "(Swampado, the sequel. I keep Scotty nicely swamped, too.)" Greg-1 says, "We could consider a variation on a theme. Charge everybody the same but reward recruiters." kokhmmm says, "Mike, it's our business to give them enough value and satisfaction so that they do renew. NSS has been using this option for years." Greg-1 says, "Oh! So if I want to join NSS (again) does that mean I should find a local chapter and get a cheaper rate?" kokhmmm says, "The $20 electronic membership is like a test drive, or trial offer. Such offers are almost universal in business" Greg-1 says, "Hmm... on the other hand, NSS membership has been declining along with everybody else's, so that might not be an endorsement of the policy." kokhmmm says, "Not available to anyone already in our database, Greg" Greg-1 says, "Rats! :)" Greg-1 says, "So really it's an 'introductory membership'." kokhmmm says, "I say we have little to lose. We also need to grow the chapters, and this would help them " MikeD-2 says, "that's true" Greg-1 says, "Would we be better off just having a shorter-term introductory membership? Say six months at half price?" kokhmmm says, "Yes, but an introductory membership only available thru chapters" Greg-1 says, "It really sounds like a good program to me." Scottyg-1 says, "I would support it with one provision..." kokhmmm says, "We could do that Greg, but we risk that six months may not be long enough for the recruit to really see what we are about" Greg-1 says, "Although the idea of an $18, 6-month, non-voting membership would probably accomplish the same thing." Scottyg-1 says, "We designate it to be a one-year trial and reconsider at the end of the year." Severy-6 finally managed to stand on top of the world! Sorry, I digress :-) kokhmmm says, "Non-voting is a trivial thing, especially since for half the people, their six months might not include an election" kokhmmm says, "We lose no more than we now do with students and seniors, as it included electronic newsletter only." dcarson says, "I'd say lets try it, we need to try things to get membership up" kokhmmm says, "If they want hardcopy, they come in at $35 like everyone else." MikeD-2 says, "if we do this, i suggest making hardcopy the default for regula North American members" garygray says, "I think Dana ans Scotty have the right idea, let;s give it a try!" irs says, "Mensa doesn't offer a discounted "trial" membership. It offers only membership at the annual rate, and discounted rates for renewals longer than one years. SFWA doesn't offer a discounted membership; only an annual or a lifetime membership. Are we selling Moon Society membership as a magazine subscription (the model that I know which does offer discounted intro offers) or as membership in a valuable organization (in which case, is the intro discount offer going to put us in the wrong light)?" kokhmmm says, "The whole idea here is to help chapters and outposts grow!!!!!" MikeD-2 says, "maybe we should charge more and include Artemis magazine with membership" john-r says, "xbbbbbb1111111111111s" Greg-1 says, "010011100100111010100100" MikeD-2 says, "the main thing is we need to do *something*" dcarson wonders if John needs the Heimlich manuver Scottyg-1 says, "One question we really don't have any data to answer is....what effect does dues have on membership?" john-r says, "sorry" kokhmmm says, "The Moon Society need not publicize this offer. It is for chapter and outpost people to use to recruit." MikeD-2 says, "John saw a can of Duff" john-r says, "thta was my wifes pet rabit" Greg-1 says, "I'm puzzing over that same question, Scotty." john-r says, "rabbit" Scottyg-1 says, "I simply don't know if lower dues will be an incentive or not at our present dues rate." Greg-1 says, "It might be that there's no difference between $20 and $35, but the availability of a discount could be attractive." kokhmmm says, "Scotty, the chapters (currently only 1) and outposts need to grow or we should drop them as a farce. " Greg-1 says, "In other words, it's not the amount of the dues but rather the avialability of a discount." MikeD-2 says, "Might we be better to charge a little more and present ourselves as more exclusive than the rest?" irs says, "So try it. I do know that Mensa membership was declining for years, but leveled off about a ten years ago, and has been slowly increasing since. SFWA membership has been pretty much steady for the past ten or fifteen years." kokhmmm says, "Again, this will not be an incentive for visitors, only for people recruited by chapters and outposts." Greg-1 says, "How many Mensans and SFWAns are there, Ian?" MikeD-2 says, "you have to pass a test to be allowed spend money?" garygray says, "The idea of a first year sicount is to help chapters to gain new members?" kokhmmm says, "Yes, Gary, only that." MikeD-2 says, "but it also gains new members for the whole organization" kokhmmm says, "Of course, Mike!" Greg-1 says, "The other side of the question is 'What does it cost us to implement this for a year to see if it works?'" irs says, "50,000 Mensans; 1,500 SFWAns." garygray says, "I don't know if it will work but it's worth a try to get more members!" irs says, "So go for it." MikeD-2 says, "it will cost the time to setup the website for chapter leaders to use" kokhmmm says, "Nothing. They do not get a hardcopy. We pay LRS only 25 cents a month for their pdf file access." Greg-1 says, "The only cost I see is the time we'll need to invest in the accounting." kokhmmm says, "The rest of the $20 ($17) is ours to keep." Greg-1 says, "The labor cost to implement is not trivial but it seems like it's worth a try." MikeD-2 says, "I'm less interested in the $17 than the extra members" kokhmmm says, "How is that different from the time spent in accounting for students and seniors who now enjoy that rate?" MikeD-2 says, "what are we going to do about the google ads btw?" kokhmmm says, "The ads are paid for by _____?" garygray says, "I think should continue it for a whule longer!" MikeD-2 says, "I disagree" john-r says, "i agree on goggle continue, it takes ime to sink in" garygray says, "And try to determine why we nit gettin g ant responses, We have a message!" kokhmmm says, "Do you think the test has run long enough, Mike/" MikeD-2 says, "I don;t think we've even got one new member for our $200" Scottyg-1 says, "My take on the dues question is this...It wouldn't make much difference in my decision to join or renew Moon Society whether the dues were $20.00 or $50.00. What makes a very big difference to me is whether I perceive that the organization is accomplishing something useful. And for that purpose, growing membership is not defined as useful. Accomplishing something worthwhile outside the internal concerns of the organization is worthwhile." Greg-1 says, "I have to agree with that, Scotty." MikeD-2 says, "in other words we need to start working on some projects" Scottyg-1 says, "A discount might push me over the hump if I was already sitting on it, but I think most potential members are not close to that point." kokhmmm says, "You guys are out of touch with reality. A lot of potential members do not have the discretionary income to take that attitude about dues." SJ has arrived. Greg-1 says, "I think building the 3D realm that shows people what it will be like to live in the Luna City Cavern would count as 'something useful' that's within our current capabilities." SJ greets. Apologies. Dealing with unexpected resignation . . . not a good week around here. Greg-1 says, "We tried to do that in the MOO but folks balked at applying any rigor to the development, and it's actually more labor-intensive to to the MOO than to build the 3D world." Greg-1 says, "Hi Steve! Sorry to hear that! :(" Nancy-1 says, "Hi Steve!" MikeD-2 says, "programming the MOO is a pain" Scottyg-1 says, "I can only deal with my reality Peter, not everyone else's. I'm not a wealthy person by any means, but $50.00 is only cigarette money for a week." MikeD-2 says, "Greg, perhaps we need to look outside the box a bit and stretch our capabilities" Scottyg-1 says, "Oops, $20.00 is cigarette money...." kokhmmm says, "Can we give it a one year test, I can't scrape up a spare $50 without 2 months notice." Scottyg-1 says, "I agreed to a one year test." kokhmmm says, "And it'll b e 50 years this December since I smoked!" Scottyg-1 says, "But I think we are beating the wrong horse." MikeD-2 says, "someone tell Steve about the 3D thing" Greg-1 says, "Oh, right. In a nutshell: We are talking about building the Luna City Cavern in an on-line Adobe Atmosphere environment." Greg-1 says, "A rough prototype is on line now." MikeD-2 says, " http://www.artistichabitats.com/Atmosphere/AH3d/Lunar/LunaCity_Launcher.html" Greg-1 says, " http://www.artistichabitats.com/Atmosphere/AH3d/Lunar/LunaCity_Launcher.html" garygray says, "I think it's both new members and project, The problem is which to do first.!" Nancy-1 says, " http://www.artistichabitats.com/Atmosphere/AH3d/Lunar/LunaCity_Launcher.html" MikeD-2 says, "Winders only I'm afraid" MikeD-2 says, "Winders and MSIE" Greg-1 says, "It really requires a high-end Windows box with hotrod graphics card." SJ is on mac; if someone will mail me that thing, I will look at it later on a Win box. Heh, or maybe not - I have no access to a high-end Winbox. kokhmmm says, "Why do we need to choose, Gary? We need to work on all fronts if we are going to break out of our slump. " MikeD-2 says, "So my 64MB ATI card in my 2GHz 512 MB machine isn't good enough?" Greg-1 says, "That oughtta do it, Mike, depending on the ATI card." garygray says, "Peter you are right we need ti do bith at the same time!" MikeD-2 says, "I think the ATI card is 50% of my trouble" Greg-1 says, "Steve, Nancy will email that URL to you." MikeD-2 says, "we need to recruit and also give out existing members an incentive to stay" Scottyg-1 says, "You folks might be able to tell that I'm somewhat frustrated. In 4 years, the Moon Society has accomplished nothing except building infrastructure. Its time we change that." Greg-1 says, "You can run it on a slower machine, but it will be kinda slow and jumpy unless you have a fairly hot graphics card." john-r says, "I am for trying yje chapters /otpost 20 for the 1st year, its not a public thing, its limited to the chapters coord - Peter and the chapter team leaders" Greg-1 says, "Scotty, I agree. Do you have a specific new program in mind?" john-r says, "Good Point Scotty" garygray says, "Scotty I agree with you and the two new projects are a start!" Greg-1 says, "That's the question we've struggled with for a long time. What to do with the talent we have." MikeD-2 says, "kick out all the freeloaders and start over?" kokhmmm says, "That's why I am trying to introduce doable projects" MikeD-2 says, "design a spaceship" MikeD-2 says, "are we too lofty?" Greg-1 says, "In the past every time we've tried to start a new project, it has resulted in folks going off to do their own thing and actually reducing the manpower we can put on the Society's work." Scottyg-1 says, "No Greg, thats part of my frustration. I can't think of anything really worthwhile that we can afford to do." SJ read the account of the St. Louis convention. I go to a lot of conventions; I'll be at one this weekend. If I had something interesting to say or show, I would be happy to do so, just as I talk about Alcor when I go to conventions. Greg-1 says, "Scotty, yeah. That's why I was thinking the 3D world would be a good thing." MikeD-2 says, "Greg, Moon Society needs a project of it's own that all members can work on and will not become another entity" Greg-1 says, "That's another good point, Steve. We need to update our presentation materials." Greg-1 says, "I think we're still using material that I developed around 1996." kokhmmm says, "This virtual world is cute, but only a place to escape to instead of doing something that could count." Greg-1 says, "Peter, I'm thinking that we need to get folks involved by providing them entertainment." MikeD-2 says, "it's also only suitable for members with fast connections" SJ says, "What happened to the "Moon Sims" group that was floating around for a while? I ask because Sims 2 seems to be huge right now." MikeD-2 says, "Moon Sims -> Simshost -> Greg" Greg-1 says, "Steve, Moon Sims is still there at http://moonsims.asi.org/" garygray says, "Maybe we should make a shirt list of projects we would like to do . Put $ figutres on them. And decide if you have the resources for a project or could get resources for a project.!" john-r says, "i need to use the phone again back in a bit" Greg-1 says, "That tale grew in the telling. See http://www.simshost.com/" john-r has disconnected. kokhmmm says, "People can find entertainment for free. What they want is a chance to help make the dream happen." MikeD-2 says, "shouldn't we be tinkering with electronic stuff or communications or research or analysis or hardware?" kokhmmm says, "I am not at all opposed to the Lunar simulation. But it will not satisfy those who yearn to belong to an organization that is trying to go somewhere." Greg-1 says, "Peter, I'm thinking that we can reasonably expect that about 5% of the members of an all-volunteer organization will actually do something. The rest provide the financial basis for that work and an audience that provides the encouraging applause." john-r has connected. SJ looks at simshost front page. Okay, clearly you're all over that already. MikeD-2 says, "I'm trying to get back into electronics and play with robots, i can think of several people who can work with me in an online co-operation" Greg-1 says, "Steve, yeah. The Sims 2 is taking over that community." Greg-1 says, "I'm also thinking that we need an attractor." Greg-1 says, "An online 3D lunar environment is interesting enough to attract some media attention." Greg-1 says, "It also can be an educational outlet. Mary says she could set up a guided tour, once we have a lunar city to tour." MikeD-2 says, "3D stuff hasn't fared well over the last 4 years, a lot of companies went bust, those that survive are scraping by" Greg-1 says, "That happens in the market for all new technologies, Mike." kokhmmm says, "Unfortunately, what succeeds is violence. Ours would be peaceful and engross only nerds" MikeD-2 says, "Atmosphere hasn't had an update for almost 2 years, Active Worlds is just the same as it was but with fewer members and fewer worlds" Greg-1 says, "The guided tour could be very educational, and attract school classes to visit." garygray says, "Greg I think a 3 D lunar envirnoment is a good idea. But it's not the sole method of achejinf the Societ goals.!" Greg-1 says, "Gary, it's the only thing I can think of that we can do right now with the resources available." Greg-1 says, "We need to focus on some project and get it working instead of burying ourselves in lots of projects that nobody has time to do." john-r needs to sleep, lots of good things in the works, night all dcarson says, "everyone think of things an email them to leaders for next meeting?" john-r has disconnected. garygray says, "Well, until we know what projects re or could be useful, we din't know if we can get new resources.!" dcarson says, "and then we can see what one(s0 to focus on" MikeD-2 says, "yes, but we need to get more people involved in the project and also try to get it into our domain so our own people can work on it, not just Mary" kokhmmm says, "I've received only positive, enthused email so far Greg. " SJ gets mail from Nancy re Lunar City. Thanks. kokhmmm has disconnected. Nancy-1 says, "You're welcome, Steve." garygray says, "Mike that's the 'problem' getting people and /or money to do projects or to do projects to get people and money!" MikeD-2 says, "is someone going to send me those word docs" irs says, "I'm gonna have to get some sleep. Sorry to have been so absent the last few weeks; after the broken computer, others things have popped up. And while I'll again be off-line next Wednesday night, I hope to more available in the future. As always, I do read my e-mail, and the telephone works just fine. Good night, all." MikeD-2 says, "chicken'n'egg" irs has disconnected. Greg-1 says, "Darn, we lost Peter. I didn't understand his note about email." Severy-6 says, "Who has the latest renewal letter templates? Greg? Scotty? Nancy?" MikeD-2 says, "I agree we should try his idea, I just think we need to do other stuff too" garygray says, "Tea, hopefully Peter will be back soon.!" Greg-1 says, "Lemme look, Randall. I think I have them." The housekeeper arrives to cart john-r off to bed. Greg-1 says, "Merde. I can't find 'em. :(" dcarson says, "your robotics mention has made me think, design and build a micro-rover?" The housekeeper arrives to cart kokhmmm off to bed. Greg-1 says, "That would be neat, Dana, but I don't think we have the resources avialable right now." SJ says, "This is a tautology, but people won't get involved in something unless it can involve them. Either their help has to be really useful, or it has to be FUN." Greg-1 says, "Randall, can we install this 3D gizmo on PB7?" The housekeeper arrives to cart irs off to bed. garygray says, "That's probably true, Greg. but what resources to we need?!" Greg-1 [to develop]: a microrover robot, we'd need a team of electronics and mechanical engineers who have the time and talent to put into it. We'd need a project leader. We'd need someone to design the mission and create the specifications. Severy-6 says, "What are the server components of the 3D gizmo, Greg?" MikeD-2 says, "exactly Dana, how about a teleoperated microrover, we could simulate the comms delay over the interent" MikeD-2 says, "internet too" Greg-1 says, "For it to be a convincing lunar exploration robot we'd need lots of money for photocells and communication electronics." MikeD-2 says, "Greg, it doesn't have to be very convincing, it just has to be a hands on research project" SJ says, "Would it be easier to build one, or to sim one? A real one would be neater, but a sim one could serve many users at once." Greg-1 says, "Randall, the Adobe Atmosphere server is available for free from Adobe. We need to request their permission and they'll give us access to the software. I don't know what the software is." Greg-1 says, "That's a neat idea, Steve." MikeD-2 says, "Steve we could sim one with an aim to build it when the sim is completed sucessfully" dcarson says, "the threashing out the mission and specs for the reference mission was I think part of what kept people interested when we started" Greg-1 says, "Mike, yeah." SJ says, "A sim one, of course, could be placed in any environment, with any delay . . ." dcarson says, "so it might get people interested doing that again" garygray says, "I think it's something we can really look into it!" Greg-1 says, "Steve, Mary Cooper says she already knows how we could do that in Adobe Atmosphere." SJ says, "Cool." Greg-1 says, "That would be neat. You could drive a little rover around on the lunar surface and manipulate things. Or you could take the elevator down to the cavern and decorate your lunar home. Lots of entertainment and lots of education." garygray says, "It's late and I need to leave. Good night, all!" garygray has disconnected. SJ says, "Race rovers." SJ says, "Treasure hunt competition with rovers." Greg-1 says, "Erm... battlebots? :)" Greg-1 says, "Car Wars on the moon! :)" SJ was SO not going there. MikeD-2 says, "Amy and Andy might be able to help also" Greg-1 says, "Sorry, I couldn't resist it. :)" SJ says, "It would add interest, at the risk of bruising the theme." Greg-1 says, "That's a good point, Mike. It can't hurt to have a couple of MIT PhD robot technonerds as advisors. :)" MikeD-2 says, "Also, Dave had made a start on one himself" MikeD-2 says, "but that was actual hardware" MikeD-2 says, "thing is, it's something that our techy types could work on and also someting our non-techy types could test by playing with it" Scottyg-1 says, "I think its time for me to call it quits for the evening. G'nite!" Greg-1 says, "G'night, Scotty!" MikeD-2 says, "If you can idiotproof it enough so Ken Williams Jr can't break it then it's a tank" Greg-1 says, "Huh?" The housekeeper arrives to cart garygray off to bed. MikeD-2 says, "lol" Nancy-1 says, "Good night, Scotty." MikeD-2 says, "Hast thou forgotten Ken so soon?" Greg-1 says, "I haven't forgotten Ken. I was wondering what we need to idiotproof and what it means to be a tank." MikeD-2 says, "a tank, as in tough" MikeD-2 says, "idiotproof the robot" Greg-1 says, "Oh! I get it!" SJ says, "Less fun to drive if it's idiotproof. You ought to be able to send it down a crevasse." MikeD-2 says, "aww heck, I'm on my second wind now" Greg-1 says, "You're thinking that a remotely controllable robot needs to sufficiently robust that a casual user can't break it. No arguement there!" MikeD-2 says, "You want to ba able to send it down a crevasse, but you want to be able to get it back up too" SJ says, "And you don't want to give people the idea that NASA's job is easy. OK, are we talking about a real robot or a sim?" Greg-1 says, "Steve, that would make a great challenge to build into the simulated robot." MikeD-2 says, "Steve, yse" MikeD-2 says, "Steve, yes too" Greg-1 says, "The last thing you see on your view screen is the bottom of the Hadley Rille approaching you at 100 mph." SJ says, "A real robot is not expendable. A sim is like a flight simulator - if you can't crash it, it's not much good." SJ says, "Greg, right!" Severy-6 says, "Greg, I have printed off the Atmosphere Server agreement and I'll fill it out and mail it to Adobe" Greg-1 says, "Thanks, Randall! That's great!" MikeD-2 says, "it doesn't say what it runs on does it Randall?" Nancy-1 says, "Oh goody!!" SJ hmms. Would you be falling at anywhere near 100mph? Never mind, geek question. Greg-1 says, "Randall, Mary says she is sending you a cyberkiss. :)" Severy-6 says, "No, Mike, I'm still trying to find details, but they provide the source, so hopefully it will be easy enough to compile on pb7" MikeD-2 says, "ah, I didn't see the part about the source" Greg-1 says, "Steve, yes, we figured that out a little earlier in the meeting. Falling 400 feet in lunar gravity gives a final velocity of 65.5 ft/sec. So about 50 mph." SJ says, "That sounds more credible. Of course, if you gunned your engine first you'd have a horizontal component. Still, plenty fast enough to smash you." SJ imagines showing the bottom of the rille as full of wrecked rovers . . . ! Greg-1 says, "LOL" MikeD-2 says, "about the same as falling from 67 ft on earth" dcarson says, "so your second trip is to salvage all the parts left from the first trip" MikeD-2 says, "or a 10-12 story building" Greg-1 says, "Dana, yes! Great idea!" MikeD-2 says, "it has to be possible, but difficult, for the rover to climb back up" dcarson says, "this looks like we like playing with it, so maybe the membership would also" dcarson says, "why don't we start a thread on the main list" Greg-1 says, "Dana, I'm thinking we should keep the project quiet until there's something that people can play with." Greg-1 says, "Marketing equation: satisfaction = experience - expectations" Greg-1 says, "You don't want to raise people's expectations before there is something for them to experience." dcarson says, "I thought that part of playing would be the design, that got lotrs of interst for the reference mission" SJ says, "How many people can work on the design?" MikeD-2 says, "we need to approach some of the more qualified members in this regard first, designing the look and feel and even some of the capabilities could be part of the fun, but the core needs to be in place first" SJ says, "Is it better to get something work - What Mike said." MikeD-2 says, "not sure Steve, we'd need Amy and Andy to point us in the right direction first" Greg-1 says, "Yeah. This broth won't turn out too well with too many cooks." MikeD-2 says, "The sim software is critical, I believe there are already some available, but I don't know where. The gui and the game aspect can come later" MikeD-2 says, "Amy has been back on the last couple of days, so I may get a chance to ask her" MikeD-2 says, "her time is somewhat limited though" dcarson says, "new baby, new job, new house, what could be keepin her busy" Greg-1 says, "She's spending all her time playing The Sims 2." MikeD-2 says, " http://www.adobe.com/products/atmosphere/showcase/featuredworlds/rc_cars/index.html looks like it might be worth looking at for ideas" MikeD-2 says, "then there's http://www.driveonmars.com/" Severy-6 just turned on gravity while flying around the top of the tower :-) Severy-6 says, "He bounced four stories :-)" Greg-1 says, "LOL" MikeD-2 says, "after you hit the ground?" Greg-1 says, "That RC car racing environment on the Adobe site looks like a perfect foundation for driving a lunar robot." Greg-1 says, "Mary Cooper says we can do that." MikeD-2 says, "the http://www.driveonmars.com/ one would give some ideas for a real robotic rover" Severy-6 says, "Yes, after I hit the ground, Mike :-)" MikeD-2 says, "I wonder has gravity been reduced to 1/6th" SJ says, "Now. Can we find real moon maps and something to let us translate them into real rover environments?" Severy-6 says, "Doesn't look like it, Mike, I fell pretty fast :-)" Greg-1 says, "Steve, yes, I think we can do that." Severy-6 says, "I just tried it again, this time walking off the edge of the top platform :-)" SJ imagines a group cooperating, taking shifts, driving a rover pole to pole. SJ says, "For charity?" MikeD-2 says, "that's tricky, the best moon maps are hard to convert, and all the rest are the equivalent on a large globe, not enough detail by far" MikeD-2 says, "Moon maps are a Dale or Vic job" SJ says, "Then the next question would be: can we get the gross info in there and fake the detail convincingly?" Greg-1 says, "Right. The last time I checked -- several years ago -- there was not a good detailed lunar globe available." Greg-1 says, "We'd have to develop our own, and fake a lot of it." Greg-1 says, "Oh. What Steve said." Greg-1 says, "It would be neat to be able to tour around and see the landing sites and crash sites." SJ says, "This gets back to what I was talking about last time: if we had a *whole moon* in sim, people could build their own colonies wherever . . ." MikeD-2 says, "the best moon data is only about 150MB in total, and it's in some sort of special format that only people with Windows 3.1 can decode" SJ says, "Cooperate to create transportation systems . . ." Greg-1 says, "Oh yes! Once we get that started we could build the translunar tram lines!" Greg-1 says, "And have places where you could drive a rover and get out at the tourist traps." MikeD-2 says, "why trams when you can launch into the sky so easily" Greg-1 says, "Because if you launch on a rocket you have to land on a rocket." MikeD-2 says, "so" Greg-1 says, "That rocket-supported vehicle that they showed in 2001 was kinda silly." Greg-1 says, "It would need to get to orbital velocity to avoid burning incredible amounts of fuel on a trip like they showed in the movie." MikeD-2 can't remember that MikeD-2 says, "ah, yes, for short trips rockets are about as useless as 747s on earth" Greg-1 says, "I'm thinking of the vehicle that they took out to see the monolith." Greg-1 says, "It was a bus with lots of rocket nozzles on the bottom. Dumb." SJ says, "If we're getting fancy, of course, you can drive real "manned" vehicles as well as the rover." Greg-1 says, "That's what I was thinking, Steve." Greg-1 says, "The vehicles could grow as the world grows." SJ says, "Perhaps anybody can drive a rover. Guest privs, so to speak. But you have to create a character on the Moon to drive a Moon vehicle." MikeD-2 says, "I know what you're talking about, I just can't recall it right now, I'll have to watch it again, after I exchange my disfunctional DVDRW drive" Greg-1 says, "The potential for generating interest in the moon is amazing." MikeD-2 says, "all that centers around believable lunar terrains" MikeD-2 says, "I think I have the lunar topography data on a CD somewhere, but I've never been able to make use of it" Greg-1 says, "That would be a start, Mike." Greg-1 says, "We need a lunar surface that we can explore and also dig into." Greg-1 says, "We can make guesses about lava caves near the surface." Greg-1 says, "And the details of other obstacle.s" Greg-1 says, "obstacles." Nancy-1 says, "I'm sleepy! Good night, all!" dcarson says, "gnight" SJ says, "It would be interesting to write an algorithm creating believable terrain which would then have to be discovered." SJ says, "We know there are lava tubes around here somewhere . . . " Greg-1 says, "Yes, exactly that, Steve." Greg-1 says, "We might even guess right in a few cases! :)" Greg-1 says, "For instance, I expect that we will find lots of lava tubes at the perimeter of the great impact basins, where there was a lot of magma flowing a few billion years ago." MikeD-2 says, "I dont quite understand how lava tubes form" SJ says, "Obviously we will have to document the assumptions that go into our terrain generation, so the users can argue!" dcarson says, "the top and sides of the flow cool first and the inside keeps flowing" MikeD-2 says, "ah, ok" Greg-1 says, "That'll keep 'em interested for years! :)" MikeD-2 says, "thus leaving a hollow structure rathe like a large cocoon" Greg-1 says, "Sort of like how the answer to the ultimate question of life, the universe, and everything kept philosophers employed for 10 million years." Greg-1 says, "Mike: http://www.asi.org/adb/02/01/lava-tube-formation.html" MikeD-2 says, "10 *million*?" Greg-1 says, "That was from The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy." MikeD-2 says, "oh, right" MikeD-2 says, "which is set in the far far distant future" SJ says, "Actually, the recent past, but who's counting?" Greg-1 says, "Well, actually, the setting for the adventures of Arthur Dent starts with approximately tomorrow." SJ says, "It just assumes the galaxy has been civilized for a long, long time." SJ says, "Well, it might be in the near future, but I think it was about 15 years ago and we just didn't notice when the world ended." SJ <- not helping here! MikeD-2 says, "ok, that little animated graphic explains a lot to me" Greg-1 says, "Not a bit, Steve! :)" Greg-1 says, "Oh good! That's why I made it, Mike!" Greg-1 says, "Golly, talk about Yesterday's Glories! That thing is 7 years old!" MikeD-2 says, "I suppose you watch AbFab and Monty Python and Blackadder and all those too" Greg-1 says, "I've seen Monty Python; don't recognize the other titles. But I do enjoy unrepentent silliness. :)" MikeD-2 [to be]: honest Greg, most of your work on ASI is more than 4 years old MikeD-2 says, "To be honest Greg, most of your work on ASI is more than 4 years old" Greg-1 says, "Yup." SJ says, "Blackadder is definitely unrepentantly silly. For my money it's also over-noisy and over-broad. But definitely silly!" Greg-1 says, "Worse than Monty Python?" MikeD-2 says, "No" MikeD-2 says, "I can watch Blackadder, Monty Python bores me" Greg-1 says, "I've enjoyed some Monty Python adventures, but yeah, most of 'em don't hold my attention." MikeD-2 says, "But then I was watching Monty Python in 1974 or something" Greg-1 says, "Often their jokes will strike me as funny weeks later. Such as the tennis match against the blanc mange." MikeD-2 says, "back when it was a weekly TV show on BBC2" Greg-1 says, "Maybe it benefits from being compressed into a few seconds of memory rather than being endured as a 1/2-hour show." MikeD-2 says, "those were the days when David Attenborough (sp?) was DG of BBC2" Greg-1 says, "DG?" MikeD-2 says, "Director general" Greg-1 says, "OIC" MikeD-2 says, "Attenborough of the nature films fame, not the one who directed Gandi" Greg-1 says, "I was unaware that there were two David Attenboroughs in the business." Greg-1 says, "I do remember a David Attenborough who narrated a lot of films." MikeD-2 says, "sorry, those would be David and Richard, not two Davids" Greg-1 says, "OIC." MikeD-2 says, "****er" MikeD-2 says, "this OIC biz is *so* john-r" MikeD-2 says, "he only does it when he wants to annoy me" Greg-1 says, "Oops." Greg-1 says, "Sorry; it's programmed into my fingers." Greg-1 says, "Ahem: 'Oh! I see!'" Greg-1 says, "Better?" MikeD-2 says, "nothing's ever better" Greg-1 says, "I'm fading out here, so I'd better call it a night." MikeD-2 says, "always worse" Greg-1 says, "LOL! Now *that* sounds like a Douglas Adams character!" MikeD-2 says, "you're fading, what about me, it's 10 to freaking 6" Greg-1 says, "Specifically, Marvin the Maniacally Depressed Robot." Greg-1 says, "And on that thrilling note: It's a night." Greg-1 says, "G'night guys!" MikeD-2 says, "night" Greg-1 has disconnected. The housekeeper arrives to remove Greg-1. MikeD-2 has disconnected. The housekeeper arrives to remove MikeD-2. dcarson says, "looks like the meetings over" SJ grins. SJ decamps. Later, all. SJ has disconnected. -- End log: Thursday, October 7, 2004 12:56:38 am ASI Meeting Server time--